Like the place, the vibe, the food, the location. Service was good too. Will be back for more.

Beautiful location right on the water with a great seafood menu. The staff was friendly, the food was delicious, the ambiance awesome! Love the extra touch with the edible orchid too. The only draw back I had was the bitter seemed like oil and not real drawn butter. Would recommend

There were four of us that came here to us got the lobster with mashed potatoes that was delicious. My husband got the special with the steak and crabcake which she said was delicious and our friend got them lobster and shrimp mac & cheese and he said it was delicious.

When in Ithaca I always stop in for dinner. They have a good location on the water with a large parking lot. I always have a great meal with good service. All the seafood is great.

The ambiance is good for family's and groups. Would not say dates necessarily. Definitely draws a crowd but there is room. One side felt very " sports bar" like but the rest was upscale restaurant feel. Located at base of Cuyagoa lake. Great view. The food was good - appetizers plenty and tasty. I was full by the time the main course came. Waiter was attentive and friendly. Would go again. I accidently labeled the tortilla appetizer as fresh fry in the pictures

The Boat Yard Grill is cute spot in Ithaca for date nights/more "special" dinners. (Although the interior kind of reminds me of an early 2000's Red Lobster chain store... I'm only looking past it because we are in Ithaca, NY). We ordered a seasonal Sugar Cookie Martini that was super fun to drink because of the sprinkle-dipped sides. It was a sweet, creamy cocktail that was actually pretty strong. I really enjoyed this one. For dinner, we ordered the Spicy Tuna Roll (nothing too special, it tasted like a spicy tuna roll so it was good). We also ordered the Lobster & Shrimp Sliders, the Scallop Stuffed Shrimp. I really enjoyed the Scallop Stuffed Shrimp. There was a creamy, gravy-like sauce served with the scallops, cornbread stuffing, and shrimp. One gripe I have with this dish was that it cost $33 but there were only 3 pieces of scallop/shrimp. Way too overpriced IMO.For dessert, we got the Molten Chocolate Cake. The dessert tasted good but it was nothing too spectacular/out of the ordinary. There was no chocolate oozing from the cake center either which disappointed me slightly. I would not make a big deal out of coming back here again but overall I had a good experience/dinner.

I really enjoyed this restaurant. It has a nice little spot right on the water and they've got the outside set up nicely so you can sit out there to relax or wait for your table. Our waitress was fantastic and I wish I could remember her name. She had some great recommendations and was super friendly. One option on the menu that I loved was that you can get smaller portions of certain entrees. I got the small plate portion of the markers mark sirloin which was very good! I also treated myself to the sizzling cookie which was awesome! I would absolutely recommend this restaurant if you're visiting Ithaca. I can't wait to go back!

We came here for dinner after my daughter's graduation. We called ahead at 11am for a text ahead dinner reservation for 5 at 4:30pm. By 4:45pm we were seated in a booth. We all ordered the halibut special $34 a plate and then a seafood Diablo. Halibut came with spinach and rice. Rice was on the salty side so I didn't finish it. For dessert we tried the chocolate cake for two, molton chocolate cake, and sorbet. The waitress was attentive even though they were packed. Including tip the bill was $260